Kelly & I recently moved into our own place about a month ago. This is huge for us, because we really haven’t had our own space for a couple of years! There are days I feel like I’m living as a newly wed all over again, even though we’ve been married for 4 years this Summer. I blame this on living with room mates and in laws.
In celebration of living in our own space I have been baking and cooking whenever I have the chance. I haven’t been able to spend the quality time in my kitchen I have been longing for, but I’m still getting some things done. Lately I have been baking lots of chocolate chip cookies. I have tried a couple different recipes, and each of them have had their own unique, yummy qualities. However, the last batch I made has got to be some of the best chocolate chip cookies I have ever made. I know, I know – EVERYONE says that. But these cookies seemed like they were going to flop, and they didn’t! So, here is my best attempt at telling you what I did to make these delicious, beautiful morsels of happiness.
FYI – oatmeal is an ingredient in this recipe, but it’s not enough to really classify the cookie as an oatmeal cookie. It just adds a little extra chewiness and texture to the cookie.
2 Sticks of Butter, softened
2 Eggs, room temp (VERY important to have them at room temp!)
3/4 cup White Sugar
3/4 cup + 2 Tbsp Brown Sugar
1 tsp Salt
1 tsp Baking Soda
1 tsp + extra splash of Vanilla Extract (pure is best if you have it)
2 1/4 cup All Purpose Flour
3/4 cup Oats (I used Quaker, not instant)
1 bag Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips (the real deal, okay, not those “chocolate flavored” imposter’s…)
If you have a mixer you have been ignoring lately, this is a beautiful time to give it some exercise. Cream together the butter and sugars for 3 minutes (the time is VERY important!). Add in the vanilla extract and 2 eggs and mix again for at least 2 minutes until everything is creamy and light. Now you can add the salt, baking soda, and flour. I added the flour in 1 cup at a time and mixed it in completely before adding the next cup. I think this mainly helped to not have flour “poof” out at me, but you never know.
Toss in the oats and feel free to use the mixer still at this point. Once the oats are incorporated add in the chocolate chips but do not do this with your mixer. Mix/fold these in with those muscles God gave you.
Now, here is the weird part… I’m sure you could bake these now and they’d be wonderful. However, I ran out of time and put the dough into a tupperware container and stored it in my fridge. When I returned to the dough today (24 or so hours later) the dough seemed very dry, and I was nervous. But, all this means is you need to give the dough a little extra love.
Spoon out about a heaping tablespoon or so of the dough and roll/mash it together into a ball. Place the cookie balls onto an ungreased cookie sheet and then bake them in that happy oven (that you preheated at 375 degrees) for 8 – 10 minutes. (Mine turned out perfectly at 9 minutes, but each oven has a mind of its own.) When you pull them out of the oven they’ll be slightly browned on top, but part of them will look like you should let them bake a little longer. DON’T. They are beautiful, just the way they are.
Place the cookies onto a cookie rack to cool & then share with whomever you find fit! But trust me, indulge yourself – let a cookie or two cool for a couple minutes and then enjoy it while it’s still warm.
HAPPY BAKING!

